Robinson Nielsen Legal represented the successful defendant, Mineralogy Pty Ltd, in a commercial dispute in the Supreme Court of Western Australia that proceeded across 33 hearing days from February to April 2022.
The full judgement is available to read here: https://shorturl.at/5tXVn
Judgment
Judgment followed a lengthy and complex trial involving a voluminous documentary record, with the Court (Martin J) delivering reasons (SINO IRON PTY LTD -v- MINERALOGY PTY LTD [No 15] [2023] WASC 56 judgment) spanning some 637 pages and with an additional 300 pages of annexures.
Background to the proceeding
The parties to the proceeding were proponents of a large magnetite ore mining project conducted upon tenements owned by Mineralogy and leased to the appellants, CITIC Limited, and its subsidiaries, Sino Iron Pty Ltd and Korean Steel Pty Ltd (CITIC parties). The project, situated in the Pilbara region of Western Australia, has been carried on since around 2008 pursuant to a suite of agreements between the parties (and a State Agreement). The project is stated to involve an estimated capital expenditure by the CITIC parties of over $12 billion.
Relief sought by the plaintiffs
The plaintiffs sought relief compelling Mineralogy to take certain steps to ensure the continuation of the project, including by submitting proposals prepared by the plaintiffs to the Minister under the applicable State Agreement, and granting additional tenement areas to the plaintiffs for no additional consideration. The asserted basis was that tenure over those areas was “reasonably required” for the continuation of the project. When Mineralogy refused, in 2018 the plaintiffs brought claims in contract, under the Australian Consumer Law, and in estoppel.
The Court’s findings
K Martin J accepted Mineralogy’s position that there was no implied or express contractual obligation binding it to provide the plaintiffs with the additional tenure areas sought. He confirmed that Mineralogy is not required to subordinate its own commercial interests by providing further land to the plaintiffs for no additional consideration. Mineralogy is required to negotiate with the plaintiffs in good faith over requests for additional tenure where it is shown that those areas are “necessary, essential or critical” for the continuation of the project, but the evidence adduced by the plaintiffs did not meet that high standard. The plaintiffs’ additional claims under the ACL and in estoppel also failed.
Speak to us
Robinson Nielsen Legal advises clients across Brisbane and throughout Australia in commercial litigation. If this article raises something relevant to your situation, call us on 07 3036 0649 or email admin@robinsonnielsen.com.au for an initial discussion.
